Yeah, I know the proper to way to read a book is to start at the front and read straight through, cover-to-cover. That’s how I usually read. Sometimes. Mostly. Unless I get bored or the story moves too slow. Then sometimes I jump back and read the end. Knowing how a book ends helps you decide if it's worth your time to finish it. Peeking clears things up pretty quickly. If the end is right (not necessarily happy, but right - they're not the same), you know it’s worth finding out how it got there. And who did what along the way. You can read backwards till you find out what you want to know. Or you can go back to the front and read right. Either way works. Just remember, front to back is not the only way to get to the best part.
It’s funny how God can use random reading. Or maybe He directs it and it’s not random at all. God seems to pretty much do His own thing without consulting us. But sometimes nudges. I almost always read after I go to bed. Even if it’s really, really late; even when I’m really tired, I’ll usually read at least a little. Because it’s just what readers are compelled to do. We don’t have much say in the matter. I’m always reading a number of books at any given time on eclectic topics. You never know what mood you’ll be in, whether you’ll need something heavy or light. So there’s always a big stack of books by my bed. My very own Leaning Tower of Pisa. My friend said you can tell what someone’s dealing with in life by the books on their bedstand. I don’t know if it’s true, but it’s an intriguing posit. I'm not telling what all's on my stack. Except Growing Up Amish. It is.
It was late last night when I went to bed. I had my reading material with me. But something nudged: “Read Growing Up Amish.” You know those nudges. The ones you don’t really want to listen to, but you do anyway, because you never know if it's God or not. If it's Him, you want to listen, so He'll keep talking. I'd already read Ira’s story back last year. I’ve read his blog for some time. That’s where I learned about his book; he talked about it on his blog as he was writing it. Told us about the journey from the very start when he was approached by a publisher about writing his story: his trepidation, his excitement, his frustration. Writing your life story is not for the faint of heart apparently. The gestation, the travail, the birthing: we blog readers watched the process from afar; listened to the heartbeats, anticipated the due date. When his book hit the press last year, he gave us opportunity to get special pre-order rates. I wasn’t much interested in reading his book. Nothing against him; I knew from his blog he was an excellent writer. I knew his story would be interesting. But the subject matter was too close to my own heart. I was in the middle of a similar journey. Walking through the pain and grief. Sorting through the debris. Reading a whole book about the same thing held little appeal. It was way too real. Too soon. Like doing surgery on the same spot as an earlier operation before the scar is healed. No, thanks. Maybe later.
But I kept reading people’s comments about it on Facebook, in Amazon reviews, hearing people talk about what they liked, what they didn’t, what they thought, whether they could identify or not. Maybe I should read it. Maybe I could handle it. So I did. Sort of gulped it down, reading very quickly without analyzing. I seldom analyze books I read; I think about the content, just not in an analytical way. I keep what is useful and let the rest float away. That's what I did with Growing up Amish. Or thought I did. I would find out later I hadn't even kept the best part. I had read enough Pathway material and other things about Amish that the cultural content of Ira’s book was pretty familiar. Old Order Amish and my culture, Old Order Mennonite, are similar in many aspects; there’s only one way to hitch up a horse. But in other areas the groups are very different. Almost like two completely different cultures. One area where they differ is prayer: Old Order Mennonites never ever use scripted prayers; whereas, according to Ira, that’s the only kind Amish use. Shunning differs too. Not all Old Order Mennonites shun. And when they do, it doesn’t involve eating at separate tables. At least the Old Order Mennonites in Virginia don’t. Others might. Old Order Mennonite shunning in Virginia is more about not socializing with those who leave; cutting them out of your life relationship wise. People practice this in varying degrees. Some not at all. There are other differences too – electricity, phones, solid versus printed clothing, for a few. And the music is quite different. At least for Virginia Old Orders who don’t use German. Our church songbooks are a mixture of classic hymns and some distinctly Old Order songs that few outside our circles sing, but nothing Gregorian chant style.
In significant ways though, Amish and OO Mennonites are very alike. Both groups view getting a car as the beginning of the end spiritually. Not that it is wrong for others, just for those God placed in an Old Order setting. If God put you there, leaving the setting is going against His will. And the social pressure from infancy onward that is put on everyone to remain there is similar in both settings. Likewise the psychological angst that ensues for those who don’t fit the mold and are faced with either staying and living as a misfit or leaving and disappointing the whole community. Ira’s story portrays this dilemma clearly. I thought he told his story honestly, without painting his people black or white, just saying how it was. A tale well told. From time to time, I would hear conservative people talk about his book. It always annoyed me whenever someone in the conservative setting said anything negative about it. So not everything in his book is pretty. Well, that’s truth. Not everything there is. No setting is. So let’s be honest here. I would defend his book: Ira was fair along with his honesty. I thought anyway. Maybe there were things I had missed. Maybe I should reread it. I borrowed my friend’s book again. Reread a few places. Yeah, okay, there is some stuff that could have been said more kindly. Or not at all. That is true. But still, it's an excellent portrayal of what leaving Old Order culture entails. And told with integrity. In my opinion anyway.
So I'd read Ira’s story once all the way through. And reread a few parts. Even analyzed it a little. Someone on Amazon said a better title would have been Leaving the Amish. I agreed. At first. But lately in processing my own journey, I’ve started thinking that the angst of leaving a culture is actually a lot about the growing up in it. That any story about leaving is first and foremost about the growing up. The being there. It’s in that growing up where the stuff of life, the good and the bad, gets into your heart and winds tendrils around your soul and spirit. All those memories. The bits and pieces of living. The love. The joys, the sorrows; the grief, the glad. The hard places. The happy places. The sad music. The happy music. The people. What they did; what they didn’t do. What you did; what you didn’t do. All the stuff life is about. Your heart, soul, and spirit get all wrapped up together in the growing up. It’s that tightly woven cocoon encasing everything that makes leaving so excruciating. How can a cocoon be unwound without tearing precious fiber?
I wanted to reread the whole book again sometime and really think about it. Analyze it in depth. So it lay in the stack by my bed. With many others. It sort of got lost in the pile. I was working through my own stuff. Processing. Sorting. Doing what you have to do to pry apart the grip of the past on your heart and figure out how to live in the present. Then came that nudge last night. So I picked up Growing Up Amish. "Okay, God, what do You want me to read here?" It was late. I really needed to get to sleep. I’d just read the very end of it. The best stuff’s always at the end. So I read the epilogue. Hmm. I hadn’t remembered some of this stuff. Not at all. I hadn’t known Ira had said this. So I backed up a chapter and read it. That called for more backing up. I read where he lived Amish after being converted. I hadn’t remembered that. It was getting late, but I had to find out more. I had to read about his conversion. I had obviously swallowed huge chunks in my first gulping of the story and never digested them. So what if it was late; I backed up another chapter and read some more. I kept backing up until I got to the part prior to his conversion. I had not remembered these details at all. I had not remembered Ira writing so openly and honestly about his fears. His spiritual turmoil. Of praying his first prayer. Of God’s quick answer. And the joy. The peace that followed. Of his learning to know God. Of his trying to live in his culture after his conversion. Trying to fit in while knowing God. And of it not working. No matter how much he and his people wanted it to. His feeling so alone in that knowing. And of his final leaving then. But in a whole different way this time. With peace and clarity and cleanness. And certainty. How could I have forgotten all this? This is the most significant part of the story. This is sheer beauty. And so true. Yes.
No wonder some people in his culture don’t like his story. Of course they wouldn’t. It’s backwards to what they believe. That someone would write openly about their doubts and fears. Lay on the line what actually went on both within and without. Sort carefully through everything, the good and the bad. Be open and honest about his own mistakes and failures. Look closely at it all. At everything. And then come out on the side of “No.” With clear and peaceful certainty. With no trace of rebellion. Sadness even. Deep sadness. But certainty. And peace. Deep certain peace. That's totally backwards. It takes guts and courage to be that honest about deep inner feelings and fears. About raw emotions. First of all to face them in your heart. And then to write about them. To bare one's soul to certain censure. To make yourself vulnerable in a world where silence is lauded. You just don't do that. Especially if you're a man. Certainly not in public. Unless you're on Jerry Springer's show. Or Dr. Phil's. Never if you're Amish or Mennonite. Ever. Or were. Yes, definitely backwards reading. Reading backwards gets everything out of order. It can play with your mind. Reading backwards has to be done with care. There's always the chance you'll miss something important. Something essential. Or take something out of context. You have to be very, very careful. But it is one way to get to the best part. Not the only way. Certainly not always the best way. But it can work. Truly. Especially if it’s late.